Comparing Traditional Fixturing Methods with 3D Printing for Enhanced Efficiency and Cost-Savings

By STG November 5, 2024

Unlocking Manufacturing Efficiency: Comparing Traditional Fixturing with 3D Printed Jigs & Fixtures for Customisation and Cost-Savings

In the manufacturing industry, fixturing is essential to maintaining precision and consistency. Traditionally, fixtures have been created using methods like machining and fabrication, providing tailored solutions and integration within established production processes. However, with the rise of 3D printing and advanced 3D printers from companies like Stratasys, manufacturers now have an efficient alternative. Comparing these approaches highlights how 3D printed jigs & fixtures are transforming tooling by offering significant cost-savings, customisation options, and production speed advantages.

Benefits of Traditional Fixturing Methods

  1. Customisation and Seamless Integration: Traditional fabrication methods offer customisation benefits, enabling fixtures that are designed to fit accurately within existing systems. This advantage is especially useful in setups where precise compatibility with established machinery is critical.
  2. Cost-Efficiency for Certain Applications: In-house or locally sourced fixtures can be produced at relatively low cost. Additionally, minor revisions or adjustments to traditional fixtures are typically straightforward and cost-effective, which provides manufacturers with the flexibility to update as needed.

Drawbacks of Traditional Fixturing Methods

  1. Limited Repeatability: Manual production in traditional fixturing often results in inconsistencies, which can impact accuracy and repeatability. When high precision is necessary, this limitation can be a costly obstacle over time.
  2. Longer Lead Times and Reduced Efficiency: Traditional methods can be slow, especially for high-volume or complex orders. Longer lead times create delays, which impact productivity, costs, and customer satisfaction.

3D Printing for Fixturing: A Modern Solution with Stratasys

Enter additive manufacturing—specifically 3D printing. With advanced 3D printers from Stratasys, manufacturers now have a faster, more flexible option to produce jigs, fixtures, and tooling. 3D printing presents clear advantages, from customisation and rapid prototyping to substantial cost-savings.

  1. Complex Geometries and Unmatched Design Flexibility: 3D printing enables manufacturers to design fixtures with complex geometries that are difficult or impossible to achieve with traditional methods. This flexibility optimises fixture performance, ensuring precision while supporting intricate designs.
  2. Rapid Prototyping and Broad Material Options: With additive manufacturing, designs can be rapidly iterated, which makes it easier to refine and perfect fixtures. 3D printers like those from Stratasys offer a range of materials—from high-strength polymers to temperature-resistant composites—providing versatility for various industrial needs.
  3. Faster Production and Cost-Savings: By leveraging 3D printing, manufacturers can reduce both lead times and production costs significantly. For instance, Oreck Manufacturing achieved a 65% cost reduction by using Stratasys Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) technology to create 3D printed jigs & fixtures, as opposed to traditional molding and casting. These savings improve the bottom line and allow for faster time-to-market.

Choosing Between Traditional Fixturing and 3D Printing

Selecting the right fixturing approach—whether traditional or 3D printed—can significantly impact manufacturing efficiency and quality. Both methods have unique advantages, so understanding the trade-offs in terms of customisation, cost-savings, lead times, and design flexibility is essential. In this context, Stratasys 3D printers offer a robust solution for manufacturers seeking to enhance production speed and reduce costs with custom, highly accurate fixtures.

The choice of fixturing method is crucial for meeting operational goals and improving manufacturing outcomes. While traditional methods are still viable for simpler needs, 3D printing is a scalable option for complex, high-precision requirements, offering both immediate and long-term benefits.

Conclusion

Fixturing remains a cornerstone in manufacturing, but the choice between traditional methods and 3D printing solutions directly affects production efficiency, quality, and cost-savings. By exploring the benefits of Stratasys 3D printing for custom tooling, jigs, and fixtures, manufacturers can make informed decisions that align with their operational needs and drive measurable improvements in their production process.

Call to Action: See how Solaxis Ingenious Manufacturing uses Stratasys 3D printers to create lightweight, custom jigs, fixtures, and tooling for industries such as automotive. Learn how Solaxis designed an assembly jig that’s easy to transport and reduces cycle time—delivered faster and at a lower cost than traditional metal tools. Watch the video >> (link: https://youtu.be/Xya49JHaIWI?si=FS7uJmbDp4xzDs6L)

Filter Used 3D Printers

Sort By

Industry
Industry
Application
Application
Technology
Technology
Material
Material
More
Printer Size
Printer Size

Filter 3D Printers

Sort By

Industry
Industry
Application
Application
Technology
Technology
Material
Material
More
Printer Type
Printer Type

Get Free Quote

Contact Us

Enquire For Price